NCAA All-Region – Division III
| | | |
| Region 1 - First Team | | | |
| C | Cole Palmeri | Sr. | Colby |
| 1B | Nathan Stafford | Fr. | Coast Guard |
| 2B | Christian Homa | Jr. | Salve Regina |
| 3B | Brant Savage | Sr. | Babson |
| SS | Riley Hasson | Sr. | Johnson & Wales |
| SS | Jacob Hand | Sr. | WPI |
| OF | Matt D’Amato | Gr. | Salve Regina |
| OF | Trevor Juan | Jr. | Johnson & Wales |
| OF | Cole Lalli | Sr. | Mitchell |
| OF | Kyle McCausland | Jr. | Middlebury |
| DH | Mitch Schroeder | Sr. | Middlebury |
| UT | Francis Ferguson | Sr. | Eastern Nazarene |
| P | Sean Mulligan | So. | Salve Regina |
| P | Justin Lessing | Jr. | Middlebury |
| P | Chris Gibbs | Jr. | Mitchell |
| | | |
| Region I - Second Team | | | |
| C | Owen Davis | Jr. | Johnson & Wales |
| 1B | Beau Root | Sr. | Middlebury |
| 1B | Jackson Curtis | Sr. | Husson |
| 2B | Ernie Little | So. | Wesleyan |
| 3B | Brady O’Brien | Sr. | Colby |
| SS | Chris Borter | Sr. | Middlebury |
| OF | Marcus Forrester | Sr. | Colby |
| OF | Evan O’Rourke | So. | Salve Regina |
| OF | Cooper O’Brien | Gr. | Colby-Sawyer |
| OF | Teddy Schoenfeld | Sr. | MIT |
| OF | Malachi Pena | Fr. | Tufts |
| DH | Hunter Yaworski | Gr. | Salve Regina |
| P | Aidan Vining | So. | Johnson & Wales |
| P | Ryan McCarroll | Jr. | Wheaton |
| P | Jack Eshleman | Jr. | Hamilton |
| P | Vito Giordano | Fr. | Coast Guard |
| P | Cam Varney | Sr. | Mitchell |
| | | |
| Region I - Third Team | | | |
| C | Parker Madden | Jr. | Coast Guard |
| 1B | James Brandon | Sr. | Lesley |
| 2B | Tanner Santos | Sr. | Babson |
| SS | Mike Maher | Sr. | Wheaton |
| SS | Patrick Shrake | Fr. | Colby |
| OF | Jackson Sattinger | Sr. | Hamilton |
| OF | Dylan Schnitzer | So. | Trinity |
| OF | Michael Finch | Sr. | MIT |
| UT | Dylan Watson | So. | Colby-Sawyer |
| P | Matt Wallingford | Jr. | Husson |
| P | Max Gitlin | Sr. | Clark |
| P | Silas Reed | Sr. | Tufts |
| P | Ryan Karman | Fr. | Coast Guard |
| P | Jason Arrigo | Jr. | Salve Regina |
| P | Derek Woods | So. | Colby |
| | | |
| Region 2 - First Team | | | |
| C | Jack Morin | Sr. | Roger Williams |
| 1B | Kyle Douin | So. | Southern Maine |
| 2B | Aidan Blake | Sr. | UMass Boston |
| 3B | Brett Velzis | Sr. | Mass. Maritime |
| 3B | Cody Waterbury | Sr. | Western NE |
| SS | Johnny Knox | Sr. | Nichols |
| OF | Ryan Boyle | Sr. | Framingham St |
| OF | Justin Gouveia | So. | UMass Boston |
| OF | Brennan Hyde | Sr. | Nichols |
| DH | Garret Roberts | Sr. | Suffolk |
| UT | Harry Painter | Jr. | Suffolk |
| P | John Connolly | Jr. | Endicott |
| P | Jordan Gottesman | Sr. | Endicott |
| P | Ryan Lapierre | Sr. | Westfield State |
| P | Adam Maher | Jr. | UMass Dartmouth |
| | | |
| Region 2 - Second Team | | | |
| C | Jacob Hurrell | Jr. | Fitchburg State |
| 1B | AJ Pietrafesa | Sr. | Mass. Maritime |
| 1B | Daniel Trzepacz | Jr. | Rhode Island Coll. |
| 2B | Scott Emerson | Jr. | Bridgewater St |
| 2B | Devyn Vezina | Jr. | UMass Dartmouth |
| 3B | Andrew Possi Sr. UMass Dartmouth | Sr. | UMass Dartmouth |
| SS | Jonny Gilbride | Sr. | Suffolk |
| SS | Kevin Lindsay | Sr. | Bridgewater St |
| SS | TJ Liponis | So. | Endicott |
| OF | Joey Frammartino | Sr. | Endicott |
| OF | Aidan Hawley | Sr. | Roger Williams |
| OF | Ray Leonzi | Jr. | Eastern Conn St. |
| DH | Cole Podedworny | Sr. | Rhode Island Coll. |
| UT | Sam Palmer | Jr. | Westfield State |
| P | Kyan Bagshaw | So. | Endicott |
| P | Nathan Furino | Gr. | Eastern Conn St. |
| P | Charlie Hale | Fr. | Endicott |
| P | Dillon Ryan | Sr. | UMass Boston |
| | | |
| Region 2 - Third Team | | | |
| C | A.T. DiPina | Sr. | Wentworth |
| C | Mathew Pigeon | Gr. | Bridgewater St |
| 1B | Danny MacDougall | Jr. | Endicott |
| 2B | CJ Demers | Jr. | Gordon |
| 2B | Lucas McElroy | So. | Rhode Island Coll. |
| 3B | Bostyn Burris | Sr. | UMass Boston |
| SS | Johnny Bova | Jr. | Western NE |
| SS | Zach Donahue | Sr. | Eastern Conn St. |
| OF | Ben Jerome | Sr. | Nichols |
| OF | Nic Notarangelo | Sr. | Endicott |
| OF | Anthony Poole | Jr. | Southern Maine |
| DH | Brendan O’Neil | Gr. | Endicott |
| UT | Dylan Pacheco | Sr. | Endicott |
| UT | Matthew Wootton | Jr. | Eastern Conn St. |
| P | Nick Cannata | Sr. | Endicott |
| P | Aidan O’Donnell So UMass Dartmouth | So. | UMass Dartmouth |
| P | Evan Scully | So. | Endicott |
| | | |
| Region 3 - First Team | | | |
| C | Caleb Miller | So. | Union |
| 1B | Liam Daly | So. | SUNY Purchase |
| 2B | Michael Boccarossa | Gr. | SUNY New Paltz |
| 3B | James Murphy | Sr. | St. John Fisher |
| 3B | Freddy Forgione | Sr. | SUNY Maritime |
| SS | Tommy Kreider | Jr. | SUNY New Paltz |
| OF | Mat Bruno | Gr. | Cortland |
| OF | Brendan Espinal | Jr. | Russell Sage |
| OF | Jelani Hamer | Sr. | Oswego State |
| OF | Liam McIlroy | So. | Union |
| DH | Alex Bardi | So. | SUNY Maritime |
| UT | Tyler Reistetter | Sr. | Merchant Marine |
| P | Johnny Dougherty | Sr. | Farmingdale St. |
| P | Luis Misla | Jr. | Cortland |
| P | Nolan Sparks | Sr. | Rochester |
| | | |
| Region 3 - Second Team | | | |
| C | Logan Hutter | Jr. | SUNY Oneonta |
| 1B | Brian Norsen | Gr. | St. John Fisher |
| 1B | Jeff Stearnes | Jr. | Russell Sage |
| 3B | Joey Dwyer | So. | SUNY Oneonta |
| SS | Alex Kornblau | Sr. | Plattsburgh St |
| OF | Chris Bonacci | Jr. | Cortland |
| OF | Anselmo Joya | Jr. | St. Joseph’s (L.I.) |
| OF | Anthony Madigan Sr. | Sr. | SUNY Maritime |
| OF | Jason Story | Sr. | Utica |
| DH | John Lynch | Sr. | St. Joseph’s (L.I.) |
| UT | Sean Liquori | Sr. | SUNY Oneonta |
| P | Ethan Cetton | Sr. | Houghton |
| P | Colin Leyner | Jr. | Ithaca |
| P | Brandon Stanley | So. | SUNY Maritime |
| P | Andrew Veit | Gr. | Plattsburgh St |
| P | Xavier Zykoff | So. | SUNY New Paltz |
| | | |
| Region 3 - Third Team | | | |
| C | Ty Gallagher | Sr. | Hobart |
| 1B | Owen Parliament | Sr. | Oswego State |
| 1B | Nolan Smith | Fr. | Cortland |
| 2B | Ryan Wasserman | So. | Farmingdale St |
| 3B | Dylan Mackenzie | Jr. | Cortland |
| 3B | Kyle Zaslaw | Jr. | Union |
| SS | Mike DiFilippo | Jr. | St. Joseph’s (L.I.) |
| SS | Nick Lemire | Sr. | St. John Fisher |
| SS | Christian Pagano | Jr. | Fredonia |
| OF | Michael Ascanio | Jr. | SUNY New Paltz |
| OF | Bobby Pollock | Sr. | Farmingdale St |
| OF | Jordan Ramlogan | Jr. | St. Joseph’s (L.I.) |
| UT | Rob Manetta | Sr. | SUNY Old Westbury |
| P | Ethan Fulton | So. | St. John Fisher |
| P | John Griffin | Sr. | Ithaca |
| P | Tommy Lynch | So. | Cortland |
| P | Patrick McGuire | Sr. | St. John Fisher |
| P | Matt Sarni | So. | SUNY New Paltz |
| | | |
| Region 4 - First Team | | | |
| C | Tommy Ajjan | Sr. | Arcadia |
| 1B | Sam Angelo | Gr. | Montclair State |
| 2B | Tyler Cannon | Sr. | Rowan |
| 3B | Cam Dunn | Sr. | NYU |
| SS | Zack Bailey | Gr. | Ramapo |
| OF | Darren Hagan | Jr. | Keystone |
| OF | Garrett McIlhenney | Gr. | Misericordia |
| OF | Jason Morgan | Jr. | Rowan |
| OF | Phil Sedalis | Jr. | Rowan |
| DH | Dylan Maria | Sr. | Rowan |
| UT | Connor Maryniak | Jr. | Misericordia |
| P | Jack Haveson | Sr. | Montclair State |
| P | Mike Shannon | Sr. | Rowan |
| P | Erik Sibbach | So. | Stevens |
| P | Joe Valenti | Gr. | Misericordia |
| | | |
| Region 4 - Second Team | | | |
| C | Brock Bollinger | Jr. | Misericordia |
| 1B | Tyler Warr | Jr. | Cairn |
| 1B | Jacob Yager | Jr. | Keystone |
| 3B | Andrew Fernandez | Jr. | TCNJ |
| 3B | Aaron Santos Jr. Fairleigh Dickinson | Jr. | Fairleigh Dickinson |
| 3B | Trevor Smith | Jr. | St. Mary’s |
| SS | Justin Marcario | Jr. | TCNJ |
| OF | JT Anderosky | So. | DeSales |
| OF | Joe Comins | Gr. | Misericordia |
| OF | Nate Pallotta | Jr. | NYU |
| OF | Tyler Stone | So. | Kean |
| DH | Anthony Bruno | Jr. | Arcadia |
| DH | Shane Stossel | Sr. | Lebanon Valley |
| UT | Phil Marcantonio | Sr. | Kean |
| P | Ben Amon | Gr. | TCNJ |
| P | Josh Berzonski | So. | Penn St. Harrisburg |
| P | Sean Brennan | Jr. | Keystone |
| P | Chris Kaponis So. Fairleigh Dickinson | | Fairleigh Dickinson |
| P | Kyle Mahady | Sr. | Penn St. Harrisburg |
| P | Reece Miller | Jr. | Stockton |
| P | Rob Salvatore | Jr. | Kean |
| | | |
| Region 4 - Third Team | | | |
| 1B | Nick Argenziano | Gr. | NYU |
| 1B | John Higgins | Sr. | Ramapo |
| SS | Carlos Irizarry So Penn St Harrisburg | So. | Penn St. Harrisburg |
| OF | Kyle Adorno | Jr. | Kean |
| OF | Rich Cirigliano | So. | CCNY |
| OF | Dallas Griess | Fr. | Penn College |
| OF | Eric Recchia | Jr. | Rutgers-Newark |
| OF | Jack Tallent | Fr. | Ramapo |
| DH | Eli Somers | Jr. | Stevens |
| P | Will Conroy | Sr. | Arcadia |
| P | Joe Gonzalez | Jr. | Stevens |
| P | Jordan Gray | Sr. | TCNJ |
| P | Mikey Gutierrez | Fr. | Cairn |
| P | Jackson Malouf | Jr. | TCNJ |
| | | |
| Region 5 - First Team | | | |
| C | Caleb Cyr | Sr. | Johns Hopkins |
| C | Ryan Thompson | Jr. | Dickinson |
| 1B | Logan Yi | Sr. | Washington |
| 2B | Mike Ramundo | Sr. | Alvernia |
| 3B | Tony Rossi | Jr. | Susquehanna |
| SS | David Woolley | So. | Elizabethtown |
| OF | Chris Betler | Jr. | York |
| OF | Andrew Kell | Jr. | Salisbury |
| OF | Tim Petrucelli | Gr. | Salisbury |
| DH | Jason Kelly | Sr. | Alvernia |
| UT | Quinten Perilli | So. | Elizabethtown |
| P | Joe Alexander | Gr. | Hood |
| P | Stephen DiBattista | Gr. | Immaculata |
| P | Nathan Stein | Sr. | Messiah |
| P | Roman Tozzi | So. | Catholic |
| | | |
| Region 5 - Second Team | | | |
| C | Nick Payne | Jr. | Centenary |
| 1B | Joshua Ammons | Sr. | Messiah |
| 1B | Jack Pistner | Jr. | Gettysburg |
| 1B | Joey Wright | Sr. | Immaculata |
| 2B | Harry Genth | Jr. | Haverford |
| 3B | Jake Elston | Jr. | Scranton |
| 3B | Shawn Steuerer | Jr. | Johns Hopkins |
| SS | Bobby Leitzel | Sr. | Marymount |
| OF | Jack Balcer | Fr. | Widener |
| OF | Isaiah Parido | So. | Messiah |
| OF | Alex Shane | So. | Johns Hopkins |
| OF | Aidan Sullivan | So. | Swarthmore |
| DH | Drew Kinsey | So. | Washington |
| P | Frank Ebling | Sr. | Gwynedd Mercy |
| P | Nick Ferraioli | So. | Alvernia |
| P | David Muirhead | Jr. | Marymount |
| P | Mike Rabayda | Sr. | Haverford |
| RP | Jason Carpenter | Sr. | Scranton |
| | | |
| Region 5 - Third Team | | | |
| C | Joey Woodrow | Jr. | Juniata |
| 1B | Zach Burton | Gr. | Catholic |
| 1B | Danny Sheeler | Sr. | Salisbury |
| 2B | Kyle Brex | Gr. | Salisbury |
| 3B | Jaden Dickerson | Jr. | Cabrini |
| 3B | Michael Tinneny | Jr. | York |
| SS | Dylan Whitney | Jr. | Johns Hopkins |
| OF | Cam Day | Jr. | Hood |
| OF | Ethan Haddock | Fr. | McDaniel |
| OF | Kaden Sigmon | Jr. | Dickinson |
| OF | Evan Wagaman | Jr. | Messiah |
| P | Kieren Collins | Gr. | Johns Hopkins |
| P | Dutch DeProspero | Jr. | Hood |
| P | Daniel Johnson | Gr. | Scranton |
| P | Koll Peichel | Jr. | Dickinson |
| P | Quinn Rovner | Gr. | Johns Hopkins |
| RP | Zach Silfies | Gr. | Elizabethtown |
| | | |
| Region 6 - First Team | | | |
| C | Hunter Hollman | Jr. | Methodist |
| 1B | Isaiah Hairston | Gr. | Guilford |
| 2B | Davie Morgan | Sr. | NC Wesleyan |
| 3B | Thomas Crandall | Sr. | Virginia Wesleyan |
| SS | Jonny Wall | Sr. | Roanoke |
| OF | Tyson Bass | Sr. | NC Wesleyan |
| OF | Ben Burkhart | Jr. | Rhodes |
| OF | Zach Ferrell | Gr. | Pfeiffer |
| OF | Quinn Madden | Jr. | Lynchburg |
| OF | Matthew Sicoli | Jr. | Emory |
| DH | Ian Hancock | Sr. | Birm.-Southern |
| UT | Ben Prather | So. | Centre |
| P | Cord Butler | Sr. | NC Wesleyan |
| P | Brandon Cassedy | So. | Christ. Newport |
| P | Dylan Weber | Gr. | Christ. Newport |
| | | |
| Region 6 - Second Team | | | |
| C | Lincoln Lubsen | Jr. | Christ. Newport |
| 1B | Chandler Ballenger | Gr. | Shenandoah |
| 1B | Myles Webb | Sr. | Randolph-Macon |
| 2B | Andrew Dutton | Sr. | Birm.-Southern |
| 2B | Joey Garcia | Jr. | Berry |
| 3B | Pearce Bucher | Gr. | Shenandoah |
| 3B | Zac Graham | Sr. | Maryville |
| SS | Frankie Ritter | Gr. | Shenandoah |
| OF | Trace Cate | Sr. | Piedmont |
| OF | Colin Dunworth | So. | Maryville |
| OF | Gavin Horning | Gr. | Shenandoah |
| OF | Bryce Thacker | Sr. | Ferrum |
| DH | Ty Lowe | Sr. | Mary Washington |
| P | Gavin Riley | Jr. | Mary Washington |
| P | Zac Sohosky | So. | Rhodes |
| P | Zeke Swartz | Jr. | Piedmont |
| RP | Braden Simms | Jr. | Piedmont |
| RP | Sam Slevin | Jr. | Randolph-Macon |
| | | |
| Region 6 - Third Team | | | |
| 1B | Micah Fox | Sr. | Virginia Wesleyan |
| 1B | Cale Oehler | Jr. | Brevard |
| 2B | Brandon Mauger | Fr. | Methodist |
| 3B | Adam Bland | Gr. | Hendrix |
| 3B | Zach Wernoski | Fr. | Randolph-Macon |
| 3B | Hayden Giordano | Fr. | Roanoke |
| SS | Brandon Garcia | So. | Lynchburg |
| SS | Josh Reinhold | So. | Christ. Newport |
| OF | Nick Brunswick | Sr. | Berry |
| OF | Ryan Schwarz | Jr. | Mary Washington |
| OF | Owen Shaw | Jr. | Hendrix |
| DH | Carter Schmitt | So. | Randolph-Macon |
| P | Dalton Brooks | Sr. | LaGrange |
| P | Joe Christopher | Jr. | Bridgewater |
| RP | Zach Heavern | So. | Centre |
| RP | Kyle Lewis | Sr. | Christ. Newport |
| RP | Joey Mitchell | Fr. | Shenandoah |
| | | |
| Region 7 - First Team | | | |
| C | Harrison Poeszat | Sr. | Kalamazoo |
| 1B | Dane Camphausen | Gr. | Case Western |
| 1B | Noah Leib | Sr. | Denison |
| 2B | Alex Richter | Jr. | Marietta |
| 3B | Patrick Gillen | So. | Calvin |
| 3B | AJ Reid | Sr. | Wabash |
| SS | Jacob LaDuca | Jr. | Washington & Jeff. |
| OF | Eric Colaco | Jr. | Denison |
| OF | Edrick Padilla | Sr. | Ohio Wesleyan |
| OF | Scout Zaas | Jr. | Washington & Jeff. |
| DH | Ryan Kramer | So. | Wooster |
| UT | Jack Anderson | Gr. | Case Western |
| P | Nick Guidas | Sr. | Grove City |
| P | Will Rettig | So. | Denison |
| P | Michael Vallone | Sr. | DePauw |
| | | |
| Region 7 - Second Team | | | |
| C | Jack Lutte | Fr. | Denison |
| 1B | Avery Carnicom | Sr. | Alma |
| 1B | AJ Miranda | Gr. | Adrian |
| 1B | Jamie Perebzak | Sr. | Otterbein |
| 2B | Andrew Witte | Sr. | Mount Union |
| 3B | James Powers | Gr. | Case Western |
| SS | Nic Bruder | Fr. | Adrian |
| SS | Brayden Quincel | Sr. | Otterbein |
| OF | Erik Daugenti | Sr. | John Carroll |
| OF | Matt Jennings | Jr. | Allegheny |
| OF | Joey Marousek | Sr. | Baldwin Wallace |
| OF | Josh Minnich | Jr. | Grove City |
| DH | Drew Garth | Jr. | Washington & Jeff. |
| UT | Tyler Quade | Jr. | Mount Aloysius |
| UT | Trent Valentine | Sr. | Marietta |
| P | Zachary Breeden | Jr. | Mount Union |
| P | Jakob Charles | So. | Adrian |
| P | Noah Truax | Sr. | Ohio Northern |
| P | Tyler Walker | So. | Baldwin Wallace |
| | | |
| Region 7 - Third Team | | | |
| C | Andrew Stechschulte | Jr. | Ohio Northern |
| 1B | Nolan Lutz | Sr. | Washington & Jeff. |
| 2B | Luke Thomas | Sr. | Wittenberg |
| 3B | Alex Nemunaitis | So. | Wittenberg |
| SS | Silvio Ionadi | So. | Penn St. Behrend |
| OF | Colin Czajkowski | Sr. | Alma |
| OF | James Domer | So. | Pitt-Greensburg |
| OF | Adam McVicker | Gr. | Heidelberg |
| OF | Robbie Stuursma | Sr. | Hope |
| DH | Nick Jacobs | Sr. | Thiel |
| UT | Sam Bevin | Fr. | Grove City |
| P | Brady Hansen | Jr. | Mount Union |
| P | Joe Horoszko | Sr. | Wittenberg |
| P | Trent Johnson | Jr. | Hope |
| P | Jackson Powers | Jr. | Heidelberg |
| P | Quinn Saunders | Fr. | Case Western |
| | | |
| Region 8 - First Team | | | |
| C | Hunter Strong | Jr. | Spalding |
| 1B | Landon Mokris | Sr. | Greenville |
| 2B | Henry Mitcham | Jr. | Transylvania |
| 3B | Alex Christie | Sr. | Hanover |
| SS | Karl Peters | Jr. | Webster |
| SS | Trent Youngblood | Sr. | Transylvania |
| OF | Sam Buduris | Jr. | Eureka |
| OF | Tyler Gutsfeld | So. | Illinois Tech |
| OF | Joe Lukancic | Fr. | Aurora |
| DH | Connor Blake | Sr. | Illinois Tech |
| UT | Bobby Bartlett | Sr. | North Park |
| P | Caleb Buehrle | Gr. | Millikin |
| P | John Girard | So. | Hanover |
| P | Cameron Rayborn | So. | Spalding |
| P | Bryce Schaum | Jr. | Carthage |
| | | |
| Region 8 - Second Team | | | |
| C | Logan Gregorio | So. | Benedictine |
| 1B | Kevin Bushnell | Gr. | Benedictine |
| 1B | Michael Paxson | Jr. | Illinois Tech |
| 2B | Justin Swanson | Sr. | North Park |
| 3B | Kyle Gibson | Jr. | Millikin |
| SS | Nico Bermeo | Sr. | Aurora |
| SS | Ethan Tuttle | Jr. | Spalding |
| OF | Tysen Lipscomb | Sr. | Franklin |
| OF | Alex DiVito | Jr. | North Park |
| OF | James Theodore | Fr. | Webster |
| DH | Brennan Fisher | Sr. | Benedictine |
| DH | Nathaniel Martinez | Sr. | Webster |
| DH | Nik Panico | Sr. | Aurora |
| UT | Landon Clark | Jr. | Miss U. for Women |
| UT | Clayton Miller | Sr. | Wash.-St. Louis |
| P | Austin Pizer | Jr. | Benedictine |
| P | Cole Shamhart So.Illinois Wesleyan | So. | Illinois Wesleyan |
| P | Tyler Gronert | Sr. | Milwaukee Eng. |
| P | Caden Krystofiak | So. | Spalding |
| | | |
| Region 8 - Third Team | | | |
| C | Ryan Janssen | Sr. | Millikin |
| 1B | Derek Angelo | Sr. | Aurora |
| 2B | Colter Couillard | Sr. | Rose-Hulman |
| 2B | Evan Evola | Jr. | Webster |
| 2B | Tommy Shaw | Sr. | Millikin |
| 3B | Jackson Bland | Fr. | North Central |
| OF | Tyler Dorsch | Jr. | Conc.-Chicago |
| OF | Max Fries | Gr. | Earlham |
| OF | Kade Kline | Jr. | Rose-Hulman |
| OF | Joseph Perona | So. | North Park |
| OF | Louis Perona | Sr. | Illinois Wesleyan |
| P | Matthew Alter | Sr. | Hanover |
| P | Matt Armstrong | Sr. | Transylvania |
| P | Luke Fleener | Sr. | Greenville |
| P | Cameron Gordon | Sr. | Lyon |
| P | Riley Richard | Jr. | Marian |
| | | |
| Region 9 - First Team | | | |
| C | Daniel Rogers | Sr. | Loras |
| 1B | Eli Frank | Jr. | Wisc.-Whitewater |
| 2B | Howie Hatton | Gr. | Crown |
| 3B | Bradley Comer Sr. Wisc-Stevens Point | Sr. | Wisc.-Stevens Point |
| SS | Colin Husko | So. | Dubuque |
| OF | Jake Brosius | Jr. | Coe |
| OF | Jacob Charon | Sr. | Lawrence |
| OF | Parker Knoll | Jr. | Lawrence |
| OF | Matt Scolan | Jr. | Wisc.-Whitewater |
| DH | Brett Kiger | Sr. | Beloit |
| UT | Sam Lavin | Sr. | St. Olaf |
| P | Quinn Berglin | Sr. | Lawrence |
| P | Johnny Blake | Sr. | Dubuque |
| P | Brock Brumley | Sr. | St. Olaf |
| P | Michael Hilker Jr. | So. | Wisc.-Whitewater |
| | | |
| Region 9 - Second Team | | | |
| C | Evan Taylor | Jr. | Buena Vista |
| C | Anthony Tomczak | Jr. | Wisc.-Stevens Point |
| 1B | George Seaman | Jr. | Wisc.-La Crosse |
| 2B | Mac Born | Jr. | Wisc.-La Crosse |
| 2B | Andy Thies | So. | Wisc.-Whitewater |
| 3B | Matt Odom | Sr. | Macalester |
| SS | Mason Brock | Sr. | Crown |
| OF | Matthew Carlsen | Sr. | Bethel |
| OF | Mason Cox | Sr. | Martin Luther |
| OF | Edan Perez | Jr. | Lawrence |
| OF | Jake Surane | Sr. | Wisc.-Oshkosh |
| OF | Chris VandenHeuvel | Jr. | Wisc.-La Crosse |
| DH | Jacoby Endreas | Sr. | Wisc.-Stout |
| UT | Mason Kirchberg | Jr. | Wisc.-Oshkosh |
| P | Cael Boehmer | Sr. | Wartburg |
| P | Jack Hagen | Fr. | Wisc.-Whitewater |
| P | Aiden Pfeifer | So. | Wisc.-Superior |
| P | John Solfest | Gr. | Bethel |
| | | |
| Region 9 - Third Team | | | |
| C | Gavin Scurr | Jr. | Luther |
| 1B | Chris Knowles Sr. Gustavus Adolphus | Sr. | Gustavus Adolphus |
| 1B | Joshua Matanich | Gr. | Luther |
| 1B | Justin Sedin | Sr. | Wisconsin-Stout |
| 2B | Kale Rose | Jr. | Cornell College |
| 3B | Joe Becker | Sr. | Saint John’s |
| SS | Matt O’Leary | Sr. | Beloit |
| OF | Louie Bartletti | Jr. | Illinois College |
| OF | Eliot Jurgensen | Jr. | Wartburg |
| OF | Hayes Waddell | Jr. | Macalester |
| OF | Nate Witte | Jr. | Wisc.-La Crosse |
| UT | Bryce Crabb | Gr. | Northwestern |
| P | Trey Castile | Sr. | Simpson |
| P | Drew Hedtke | So. | Bethany Luth. |
| P | Charlie Jaeger | Sr. | Dubuque |
| P | Vince Tinajero | Jr. | Cornell College |
| P | LJ Waco | Sr. | Wisc.-Oshkosh |
| | | |
| Region 10 - First Team | | | |
| C | Adam Dapkewicz | Gr. | Claremont |
| 1B | Isaac Kim | Sr. | Pomona-Pitzer |
| 1B | Julian Sanders | Sr. | Claremont |
| 2B | Blake Wink | Gr. | Cal Lutheran |
| 3B | Riley Hood | So. | McMurry |
| SS | Noah Meffert | Jr. | George Fox |
| OF | CJ Colyer | Sr. | Pacific |
| OF | Dane Jones | Sr. | LeTourneau |
| OF | JC Ng | Jr. | Pomona-Pitzer |
| DH | Andrew Mazzone | Gr. | Claremont |
| P | Sayers Collins | Gr. | E. Texas Baptist |
| P | Julien Hernandez | Sr. | Whitman |
| P | Jake Hilton | Jr. | Pomona-Pitzer |
| P | Hannoh Seo | So. | Pomona-Pitzer |
| P | Jackson Teer | Jr. | Trinity |
| | | |
| Region 10 - Second Team | | | |
| C | Nathan Perry | So. | La Verne |
| C | Michael Smosna | So. | McMurry |
| 1B | Rhett Grosz Sr. Mary Hardin-Baylor | Sr. | Mary Hardin-Baylor |
| 2B | Tassos Foster | Sr. | Willamette |
| 3B | Jacob Evangelista | Sr. | E. Texas Baptist |
| 3B | Elijah Maris | Sr. | Linfield |
| SS | Greg Pierantoni | Fr. | Pomona-Pitzer |
| OF | Nate Jakobs | Sr. | Pomona-Pitzer |
| OF | Maxwell Mims | Sr. | Southwestern |
| OF | Aidan Warren | Sr. | Schreiner |
| DH | Adam Peavy | So. | Texas Lutheran |
| UT | Teige Barrett | Sr. | Whittier |
| P | Hamilton Finefrock | Jr. | Claremont |
| P | Cody Myers | So. | Centenary |
| P | Jonathan Newman | Sr. | Trinity |
| P | Eric Prough | Sr. | Pomona-Pitzer |
| P | Gerald Terry | Sr. | La Verne |
| P | Niko Urquidi | Fr. | La Verne |
| | | |
| Region 10 - Third Team | | | |
| C | Halen Otte | So. | Whitman |
| 1B | Chris Morrow | Sr. | Concordia |
| 2B | Dillon Martin | Fr. | Claremont |
| 3B | Jeff Hoffman | Sr. | Willamette |
| SS | Dylan Burnaman | Jr. | E. Texas Baptist |
| OF | Tanner Benson | Sr. | Howard Payne |
| OF | Connor Massimini | So. | E. Texas Baptist |
| OF | Lew Rice | Sr. | Whittier |
| OF | Brett Wagner | Gr. | E. Texas Baptist |
| DH | Xander Nabors | Jr. | LeTourneau |
| UT | Davis Franklin | Jr. | Puget Sound |
| P | Robert Croft | So. | E. Texas Baptist |
| P | Hunter Dryden | Sr. | Whitworth |
| P | Brandon Menzel | Sr. | Chapman |
| P | Adrian Montenegro | Jr. | Dallas |
| P | Jagger Neely | Jr. | E. Texas Baptist |
| P | Layton Wagner | Gr. | Willamette |
